Spatial variations in shrub thicket gap characteristics on Hog Island.

Edward R. Crawford and Donald R. Young. Department of Biology, Virginia Commonwealth University. Richmond, Virginia

In an effort to elucidate successional mechanisms involved in the development of climax maritime forests, we quantified canopy gaps which naturally occurred within (Myrica cerifera) shrub thickets on Hog Island. Thicket microclimate, spatial heterogeneity, and edaphic characteristics within canopy gaps, as well as within intact understories, were compared for productive (Mid-Island) and aging (Bay Side) thickets to discern if gap characteristics vary with thicket age.

(Fig. 1). On Hog Island, small gaps were prevalent in the younger more productive thicket, conversely, large gaps were prevalent within the aging thicket. Gaps within these contrasting thickets differed in microclimate and species richness.

Considerable differences occurred in light and soil environments between the locations as well as between gap and intact thicket. Light levels in gaps and adjacent thickets were highly variable. In the productive Mid-Island thickets, midday incident quantum flux ranged from 5-968 umol m-2 s-1 while levels in the aging Bay Side thicket ranged from 10-1000 umol m-2 s-1 (Table 1). The Bay Side gap photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) was approximately twice as high as the Mid-Island. The percent sunlit of the within gap transects was almost 4 times as high for the Bay Side gap than the Mid-Island gap (Table 1). Gap air temperatures were generally a few degrees warmer than adjacent intact thickets (Table 1). Temperatures at the soil surface were 6 (C) and 14 (C) higher for the Mid-Island and Bay Side gaps, respectively, while temperatures at -10 cm varied minimally between their adjacent thickets (Table 1).

There were 35 different species found within the gaps of both thickets (Table 2). Eighteen were woody, and 17 were herbaceous. There were a total of 10 species found within Mid-Island gaps. Myrica cerifera and Parthenocissus quinquefolia were the most prevalent species found within the Mid-Island gaps (Table 2). The Bay Side gaps however, had 3 times greater species richness than was found within the Mid-Island gaps (Table 2). Once again, both Myrica cerifera and Parthenocissus quinquefolia proved to be ubiquitous within the Bay Side gaps.

Relative to the intact thickets, gaps enhance environmental variability and provide a diversity of microsites suitable for the establishment of later seral species.



Table 1.

Microclimate summary for Mid-Island and Bay Side gaps and intact thickets at solar noon. Values are means +/- standard errors.

_____________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________

                             Mid-Island                  Bay Side
  
                          Gap         Thicket         Gap        Thicket
______________________________________________________________________________

PPFD (umol m-2 s-1)
   Sunlit 	       575+/-150      509+/-57    1050+/-95      525+/-109
   Shaded	        36+/-4          6+/-0      100+/-0        38+/-3
   Range                 7 - 1288       5 - 968    100 - 1500     10 - 1000

% Sunlit                  25             10           96            36

Tair (C) 		  28             27           30            27
 Range                  25 - 29        23 - 28      25 - 31       25 - 28


Tsoil (C)                 
   Surface     	          32             26           41            27
   Range                24 - 32        24 - 28      24 - 41       24 - 28
   -10 cm  		  20             20           22            21
   Range                19 - 21        19 - 20      20 - 24       20 - 22
_____________________________________________________________________________

Table 2.

Frequency of species found in gaps in the Myrica cerifera thickets on Hog Island.

_________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________
				        
 Species		                Frequency

                                 Mid-Island   Bay Side
_________________________________________________________

   Woody
	Baccharis halimifolia	        0.2         0.3
	Berchemia scandens               -          0.1
	Calystegia sepium		 -	    0.1	
	Celtis occidentalis              -          0.1
	Hypericum hypericoides		 -	    0.2
        Iva frutescens                   - 	    0.2
	Iva imbricata                    -          0.2
 	Lonicera japonica		 -	    0.2
	Mikania scandens		0.1	    0.2
	Myrica cerifera			1.0         0.7
	Parthenocissus quinquefolia	0.7         0.9
	Persea palustris		 -	    0.4
	Prunus serotina                  -          0.2
	Rubus argutus		        0.1         0.5
	Smilax bona-nox			 -	    0.1
	Smilax rotundifolia              -          0.1
	Toxicodendron radicans		0.2	    0.2
	Vitis aestivalis		 -	    0.1
	
   Herbaceous
	Atriplex patula                  -          0.1
	Boehmeria cylindrica		 -	    0.2
	Chenopodium ambrosiodes		 -	    0.1	
	Cirsium horridulum		 -	    0.2
	Cyperaceae spp.                 0.1          -  	 
	Eupatorium capillifolium	 -	    0.5
	Eupatorium hyssopifolium	 -	    0.2
 	Gnaphalium purpureum             -          0.1
	Osmunda regalis                 0.2	     -
	Phytolacca americana      	 -          0.1
	Poaceae spp.			 -	    0.4
	Polygonum hydropiperoides	0.2	    0.1
	Rumex acetosella		 -	    0.4	 
	Scirpus americanus       	 -          0.1
	Setaria geniculata		 -	    0.1	 
	Spartina patens         	 -          0.1
	Teucrium canadense		0.1         0.4	

   Species richness (#)                 10          33
_________________________________________________________